Busting the Eating Disorder Myths
Eating disorders are often misunderstood. You might have heard people say they are “just about food” or that someone “doesn’t look sick enough” to have one.
These statements are not only false but also harmful. They make recovery harder for those who are struggling and discourage people like you from seeking the support you need and deserve.
And when you constantly hear misconceptions about body size, willpower, or “healthy eating,” it becomes easy to internalize them as facts.
It is time to bring truth into the conversation and challenge the eating disorder myths that keep you trapped in guilt, shame, and silence.
This article will help you see eating disorders for what they truly are—that they are complex mental health conditions that deserve compassion and understanding.
Myth 1: Eating disorders are only about food
You might think eating disorders are solely about eating too little or too much. However, they are not just about food. Food is only the surface of a much deeper mental and emotional struggle.
Eating disorders often stem from underlying issues such as perfectionism, trauma, control, or self-worth. They become a way to cope when emotions feel overwhelming or when you believe you need to “fix” your body to feel accepted.
The truth is, your eating habits are often a reflection of how you are coping with something far more complicated.
Healing from an eating disorder or disordered eating involves addressing the emotional pain beneath the behaviors and not just changing what or how much you eat.
Working with a professional who understands this can help you rebuild trust with your body and rediscover a healthy, peaceful relationship with food.
Myth 2: You have to be underweight to have an eating disorder
This is one of the most damaging eating disorder myths. Many people believe that someone must look visibly thin to be struggling. This is not true.
Eating disorders affect people of every body size, shape, and age. You might appear “healthy” or even “fit” on the outside but still experience deep distress about food, eating, or your body.
When you hear that you do not “look sick enough,” it invalidates your pain. But eating disorders are about behaviors, thoughts, and emotions, not appearances.
Restricting food, obsessing about calories, bingeing in secret, or exercising compulsively are all signs of disordered eating, regardless of your weight.
Myth 3: People at a “normal” body weight cannot have an eating disorder
Another harmful myth is that individuals who are at a “normal” or “average” body weight cannot have an eating disorder. This belief can delay diagnosis and treatment for countless people.
You might think that your struggles are not serious enough because your weight falls within a certain range, but that is not true.
Eating disorders are about behaviors and thought patterns about food shame and body image, not numbers on a scale.
People at any body weight can experience the same physical and emotional consequences as those who appear underweight. The severity of an eating disorder should never be judged by appearance. You deserve support no matter what your weight is.
Myth 4: Only upper class caucasian women get eating disorders
Society has long portrayed eating disorders as something that happens only to white, upper-middle-class girls. This narrow stereotype excludes the many individuals who fall outside of that category yet still struggle deeply with food and body image.
In fact, recent findings published in Frontiers in Psychiatry highlight a growing consensus that eating disorders affect people across all genders, ages, sexual orientations, ethnicities, and socioeconomic groups. It’s also stressed in their current studies the need to understand how social determinants influence ED development and presentation, as well as to create more diversity-affirming assessment tools.
The real problem is that research on eating disorders in diverse and marginalized populations is lacking. It’s not that people of diverse backgrounds don’t struggle with disordered eating. It’s that they are disproportionately underrepresented in eating disorders research and, unfortunately, less likely to access eating disorder treatment.
You might be a person of color, part of a working-class family, or living in a different culture altogether—and your experience is still valid.
You should never feel invisible or excluded from care because your story does not match society’s limited idea of what an eating disorder “looks like.”
Myth 5: Parents are the cause of eating disorders in their children
While parents are not always the cause of eating disorders, it’s also true that family environments can influence a child’s relationship with food and body image. Many eating disorders are an issue of nature and nurture.
Eating disorders develop through a mix of biological, psychological, and social factors. Sometimes, experiences at home, such as pressure about weight, food restriction, or emotional neglect, can contribute, but they are rarely the only cause.
If you are a parent, know that your role can still make a difference. Your awareness, empathy, and support can become powerful tools in your child’s recovery and lasting healing. It’s never too late to pivot your family’s approach to food and weight in the home and create a compassionate, eating disorder-informed environment.
Myth 6: Recovery is just about eating normally again
You may think that recovery simply means eating more or less to get your- body “back on track.” But recovery is much deeper than that.
True healing involves unlearning harmful beliefs about food, letting go of guilt around eating, and finding safety in your body again.
Restoring your physical health is important, but emotional recovery matters just as much. You will need to rebuild trust in your hunger and fullness cues, tolerate living in your body after it may have changed, learn self-compassion, and understand what your body truly needs.
Here is the truth: full recovery is possible. It might not be a quick or easy process, but every small step you take, every meal you nourish yourself with, and every time you challenge a disordered thought, moves you closer to peace.
Myth 7: You can just “snap out of it”
You may have been told to “just eat” or “stop worrying so much about food.” But recovery is not a matter of willpower.
Again, eating disorders are serious medical and psychological conditions that alter your brain’s reward systems, emotions, and thinking patterns.
Telling yourself to “get over it” only adds pressure and shame. Healing requires professional support, not just motivation. You may need therapy, nutrition counseling, medical care, and a supportive community that understands what you are going through.
Myth 8: Eating disorders are a choice
No one chooses to live in fear of food or to spend hours battling thoughts about their body.
When you believe it is a choice, you may also believe you “deserve” the pain. But know this, what you deserve is understanding and care.
And just as you would not blame someone for having depression, cancer, diabetes or any other illnesses, you should not blame yourself for having an eating disorder or believe it was a choice to have one.
Myth 9: Eating disorders are caused by vanity or trying to look pretty in thin bodies
Many people think eating disorders are simply about wanting to improve physical appearance. But this myth deeply oversimplifies a painful and complex condition.
While body dissatisfaction can play a role, eating disorders are not acts of vanity or to look pretty, they are coping mechanisms and often, they are a cry for help. Recent research published in the European Journal of Investigation in Health, Psychology and Education supports this. The study showed that even among young aspiring fashion models—often assumed to develop eating disorders out of vanity—body dissatisfaction alone did not explain their symptoms. Instead, researchers found that stress played a significant mediating role between body dissatisfaction and eating disorder behaviors. This highlights that these struggles stem from emotional distress and pressure, not superficial appearance motives.
You may have learned to tie your value to how you look. Society reinforces that belief every day through social media and beauty standards. But your worth is not measured by your reflection.
When you begin to separate your identity from your body, you can start to nurture yourself for who you truly are, not how you look.
Myth 10: You will always have your eating disorder
Complete recovery is possible. Although it does not mean you will never think about food or body image again. We live in a world that is saturated by diet culture and the obsession of thinness, of course we will still wrestle with unhelpful thoughts about food and weight sometimes. But what matters is what you choose to do with those thoughts. Do they stay as thoughts? Or do you turn those unhelpful thoughts into unhelpful actions?
Remember that healing will look different for everyone. For you, it might mean learning to eat without guilt, finding peace in your reflection, or feeling connected to your body for the first time. What matters is that recovery allows you to live fully again.
How breaking these myths can help you heal
When you start to see eating disorder myths for what they are (as false, limiting beliefs) you give yourself permission to heal. You begin to understand that you are not broken and you realize that your struggles are valid and that recovery is not about perfection but progress.
You deserve to eat without fear, to move your body with joy, and to live without being defined by numbers or expectations.
At Maddox Nutrition, we believe that healing involves your whole self—body, mind, and spirit.
Our team of Registered Dietitian Nutritionists specializes in eating disorder recovery and intuitive eating.
We also provide compassionate, Christ-centered care (if you want it) designed to help you rediscover peace with food and your body.
We are in-network with most major insurance providers, and 90% of our clients pay $0 out of pocket for their sessions.
Reach out today to begin your recovery journey with a team that believes in your healing and walks with you every step of the way.
–
What you need to know
The difference between a Dietitian and Nutritionist
A dietitian is a regulated healthcare professional who has completed formal education in nutrition and dietetics, undergone supervised training, and is licensed to provide medical nutrition therapy for conditions such as diabetes, eating disorders, or gastrointestinal issues.
The title “dietitian” is legally protected in many countries, ensuring that only those who meet strict professional standards can use it.
In contrast, the title “nutritionist” is not always regulated, meaning anyone can call themselves a nutritionist regardless of training, though some may hold advanced degrees or certifications. Generally, dietitians are qualified to offer clinical nutrition care, while nutritionists often focus on general wellness and healthy lifestyle guidance.